There are a lot of quarterbacks around who have a lot of skill in the regular season but when it comes to the postseason, their hands get clammy. Baker Mayfield has seen both sides of the coin in the NFL. Through the comfort of the Cleveland Browns to work out of a huge postseason drought to ending the drought with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Mayfield has sprinkled his career with some memorable playoff games. Baker Mayfield playoff record is now 2-3 as a starting quarterback in the playoffs, having won his first career game and failed in two postseason starts.
The record does not mean that he would be considered close to NFL’s all-time postseason legends but that is just half the story. His ascension to teams, leadership qualities, and performances in tight situations have made a huge impact in regards to his reputation. When looking for a Baker Mayfield playoff record, it is essential to understand the numbers, context and impact behind their wins and losses.
Quick Answer: What Is Baker Mayfield’s Playoff Record?
He’s 2-3 overall as a starting quarterback, with a 2-1 record in the postseason.
Baker Mayfield Playoff Record at a Glance
| Category | Record |
| Playoff Games | 5 |
| Wins | 2 |
| Losses | 3 |
| Winning Percentage | .400 |
| Passing Yards | 1,338 |
| Passing Touchdowns | 12 |
| Interceptions | 3 |
| Passer Rating | 105.9 |
| Completion Percentage | 64.5% |
He has played in the playoffs with both the Cleveland Browns and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Why Baker Mayfield’s Playoff Journey Matters More Than His Win-Loss Record?
The story of a quarterback’s playing career is not always captured by his playoff season in and of itself. Context matters. Whereas quarterbacks who joined championship teams would step in and offer a bit of boasting to the outside world, Mayfield stepped in and changed where and how expectations were placed.
His mishandling of Cleveland in 2020 was the first postseason loss the team has suffered in almost 20 seasons. He followed that up with a resurgence and led the Bucs into the playoffs the following playoffs in Tampa Bay.
So it’s a combination of his hard times as well as his postseason success, and that’s why his name is seen as a lot brighter than his stats in the postseason, in my opinion.
Every Baker Mayfield Playoff Game Explained
2020 AFC Wild Card Round vs Pittsburgh Steelers
Result: Browns Won 48-37
The first playoff game of Mayfield’s career was one of the bigger nights of his career.
| Stat | Number |
| Completions | 21 |
| Attempts | 34 |
| Passing Yards | 263 |
| Touchdowns | 3 |
| Interceptions | 0 |
| Passer Rating | 115.2 |
Why This Game Changed His Legacy?
The Browns were in Pittsburgh as the underdogs, but Mayfield had no mistakes and threw three touchdown passes. What was truly important was that he was the key to Cleveland’s first playoff win since 1994.
This is still regarded by many Browns fans as one of the best victories of modern-day Browns football.
2020 AFC Divisional Round vs Kansas City Chiefs
Result: Browns Lost 22-17
Cleveland was dealt the fate of playing the defending Super Bowl champion the next week.
| Stat | Number |
| Completions | 23 |
| Attempts | 37 |
| Passing Yards | 204 |
| Touchdowns | 1 |
| Interceptions | 1 |
| Passer Rating | 74.6 |
The Browns had a rough night but their performance was close to a championship team until the very end.
Key Takeaway
But this game proved Mayfield and Cleveland were able to contend with top NFL teams. The Browns were a stroke away from their stand-up bid to the AFC championship game.
2023 NFC Wild Card Round vs Philadelphia Eagles
Result: Buccaneers Won 32-9
Rebuilding his career in Tampa Bay, Mayfield gave what was one of his best postseason performances ever.
| Stat | Number |
| Completions | 22 |
| Attempts | 36 |
| Passing Yards | 337 |
| Touchdowns | 3 |
| Interceptions | 0 |
| Passer Rating | 119.8 |
Why was this performance so important?
Tampa Bay was thought to be an Achilles’ heel before the season due to the loss of Tom Brady. Instead, Mayfield helped the Browns secure a division championship and excelled against a talented Philadelphia team in the playoffs. It forever altered how some saw his career going.
2023 NFC Divisional Round vs Detroit Lions
Result: Buccaneers Lost 31-23
The NFL’s busiest offense was coming against Mayfield one week later.
| Stat | Number |
| Completions | 26 |
| Attempts | 41 |
| Passing Yards | 349 |
| Touchdowns | 3 |
| Interceptions | 2 |
| Passer Rating | 94.5 |
What Stood Out?
Mayfield tossed for nearly 350 yards and three touchdowns despite being unable to score a touchdown. The Bucs remained competitive all game and eventually were hit with a pair of costly turnovers.
Those numbers would be welcomed at a certain point, many quarterbacks definitely would take them in a playoff.
2024 NFC Wild Card Round vs Washington Commanders
Result: Buccaneers Lost 23-20
Mayfield was still playing well in this game, but it took another defeat to his playoffs record.
| Stat | Number |
| Completions | 15 |
| Attempts | 18 |
| Passing Yards | 185 |
| Touchdowns | 2 |
| Interceptions | 0 |
| Completion Rate | 83.3% |
| Passer Rating | 146.5 |
Hidden Story Behind the Numbers
Few quarterbacks complete more than 80% of their passes in a playoff game. Mayfield was an effective product, and it became clear that he was as at ease as ever in the Bucs offense, even though Tampa Bay didn’t move on.
Baker Mayfield Stats in the Playoffs
In discussing Baker Mayfield stats, his playtime performance comes into focus more.
Career Playoff Passing Statistics
| Statistic | Total |
| Games Played | 5 |
| Completions | 107 |
| Attempts | 166 |
| Completion Percentage | 64.5% |
| Passing Yards | 1,338 |
| Yards Per Attempt | 8.1 |
| Passing Touchdowns | 12 |
| Interceptions | 3 |
| Passer Rating | 105.9 |
| Sacks Taken | 10 |
What Makes These Numbers Impressive?
Playoff passer ratings of 100 and above are considered to be an elite level of play. Mayfield has taken the Helm in the NFL and in Wentz’s absence, he has generally been the better choice when missions have the potential to get most critical.
Baker Mayfield Stats: Regular Season vs Playoffs
An interesting thing to note is that Mayfield, at least in terms of efficiency, is often at his best in the postseason.
Statistical Comparison
| Category | Regular Season Career | Playoffs |
| Completion Percentage | Around 63% | 64.5% |
| Passer Rating | Mid-90s | 105.9 |
| Yards Per Attempt | Around 7.3 | 8.1 |
| TD-INT Ratio | Strong | 12-3 |
Expert Observation
Quarterbacks tend to deplete their skill set when required to perform during playoff games—the opposition is tougher, and errors can have a hefty price tag. In general, Mayfield has trended in the wrong direction. This trend is all-too-often ignored when it comes to discussing Baker Mayfield stats.
The Turning Point That Changed Baker Mayfield’s Career
“All of the NFLers Have careers.” Mayfield’s did not. He left Cleveland, and played for the Carolina Panthers and Los Angeles Rams before settling in at Tampa Bay. There are quarterbacks that never come back from losing a starting position. Mayfield appreciated the experience to grow in decision-making, leadership and consistency. It’s seen in Tampa Bay during their playoff runs.
What NFL Analysts Often Miss About Baker Mayfield’s Playoff Record?
Many people will look at only the 2-3 record. It’s important to note several similarities:
| Achievement | Result |
| Playoff Wins | 2 |
| Teams Reached Playoffs With | 2 |
| Playoff TD Passes | 12 |
| Career Playoff Rating | 105.9 |
| Games With Multiple TDs | 4 |
| Games Above 300 Passing Yards | 2 |
These statistics indicate a quarterback that has typically done very well in Postseason pressure.
How Baker Mayfield Compares to Other Active NFL Quarterbacks in the Playoffs?
Mayfield’s playoff ability, however, is more like that of numerous league starting QBs just starting out in their postseason careers, compared to players like Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen and Joe Burrow. When he’s been given the opportunities in the postseason, he has been productive, as evidenced by touchdown assists, passer rating and yards per attempt.
Can Baker Mayfield Improve His Playoff Record?
Yes, certainly! Quarterbacks tend to establish their playoff careers later in their careers. Over the years, many NFL linemen have built up their postseason experience over years of playing on the field before getting to their big games in the playoffs.
Examples include:
- Matthew Stafford
- Drew Brees
- Steve Young
Mayfield is still in his prime and leads a competitive Tampa Bay team. If he can make some more playoff runs, it can result in helping his record.
Final Verdict
It’s not just the record that matters as Baker Mayfield is 2-3 in the playoffs. He has over 1,300 yards and 12 touchdowns in postseason passes, and has a 64.5% completion percentage with an impressive passer rating of 105.9.
But more significant is that he has played with some production in two different franchises and played stouts in the pressure cooker during the playoffs. Take a look at Baker Mayfield’s numbers, plus his postseason results, and it’s clear he’s been a quarterback who has performed well more times than he’s acknowledged in January.
If he keeps playing, he may be finding himself in the playoffs more frequently, and in a better spot in the league for being a tough quarter to beat.
Also Read About: Kirk Cousins Playoff Record: What His Postseason Results Really Say
